The Political Thought of Edmund Burke

Suggested Background:

I encourage you to read some historical background if you are unfamiliar with the basic events in America from 1754–75 or with the American and French Revolutions. You might also like to watch the PBS documentary “The War that Made America,” which is on the French-Indian War of 1754–63. This first global war created the conditions that are debated in Burke’s speeches on America.

Other Resources:

To learn more about the ideas and figures discussed in this course, we encourage you to explore a project supported by the Hertog Foundation: The Great Thinkers and Contemporary Thinkers websites. These sites are aimed at introducing important thinkers in Western thought, with a particular emphasis on politics and philosophy. Relevant pages include Plato, Aristotle, Machiavelli, Hobbes, Locke, Burke, and Smith (on The Great Thinkers).

Readings:

• Harvey Mansfield, “A Sketch of Burke’s Life” in Selected Letters, pp. 29–35
• Burke, “An Essay Towards an Abridgement of History,” (1757), excerpt
• Burke, “Thoughts on the Cause of the Present Discontents,” (1770), pp. 203–10; 268–76
  only

Discussion Questions:

Essay on English History:

1. What are the main periods that Burke sees in English history? What characterizes each? What are their particular good and bad features? How does Burke explain them?
2. How exactly does Burke explain English historical developments? How according to him did change happen? Does Burke have a “theory of history”?

Thoughts on the Present Discontents:

This is a terrific analysis of the British government of Burke’s time and what Burke considers to be legitimate and illegitimate government, but, alas, the essay is too long for our week. I recommend reading the whole thing, but am requiring only the beginning and end.

1. pp. 203–10: What according to Burke does and does not hold nations together? Consequently, what is the task of a statesman?
2. pp. 268–76: What does Burke mean by “connexion”? What exactly is he praising and why? What do you think of his idea?

Readings:

• Burke, “Speech on American Taxation,” (1774), pp. 298 [“Permit me then, Sir…”] –bottom 301; para from bottom of 328–29
• Burke, “Speech on Conciliation with American Colonies,” (1775), pp. 337–58 only
• Burke, Letter to Sheriffs of Bristol on the Affairs of America” (1777), pp. 401–11, 426–41
• Burke, “Sketch of the Negro Code,” (1780/92)

Discussion Questions:

Speech on American Taxation:

1. In this essay, Burke identifies and analyzes what he deems to be the four periods of British policy toward America. The assigned excerpt is Burke’s account of the first period, from the first settlements in America to 1764. How does Burke understand the morality of traditional British policy toward the colonies before 1764? What does he say are the benefits and drawbacks to the colonies? According to him, why do the colonies accept this policy? What provoked them?
2. This might be hard to answer based on the assigned excerpt alone, but the main questions of the essay are: what policy toward the colonies does Burke recommend and on what grounds? What principle(s) does Burke appeal to? Which does he reject?

Conciliation with the Colonies:

1. What is “conciliation”? What are the several reasons why Burke thinks conciliation is the best policy? In arguing this, to which principles does he appeal and not appeal?
2. What does Burke say is the predominant temper and character of Americans? What are the seven reasons he cites that made Americans this way (350–56)?
3. Given the American character, what does Burke deem to be the four ways of dealing with the colonies (see especially 358)? Which does he prefer and not prefer and why?

Should you wish to read on, ask yourself:

1. Why does Burke discuss Ireland, Wales, Chester, and Durham (369–74)?
2. Does Burke favor representation for the colonists in the British Parliament? Why or why not?
3. Note: the end of the speech includes Burke’s “six fundamental propositions” on America and “three more resolutions corollary to these” (376–95). I will quickly state what these are in class.

Letter to Sheriffs of Bristol on the Affairs of America:

1. Why is Burke so concerned with the partial suspension of habeas corpus law? Why according to him is the partial suspension so insidious?
2. What are Burke’s views on the following topics: prudence v. principle and the true end of legislation (426–28); liberty (430); equality (408 & 438); how and why the British Constitution is supposed to work; who Burke trusts; what makes government effective; and how to avoid corruption in a corrupt age?

Sketch on the Negro Code:

1. What is Burke’s view of Africans? Are they fully human?
2. What does Burke think of slavery? What does he propose to do about it? Is his plan partial or comprehensive? What are its main features and why?
3. Insofar as Burke advocates change, is his proposal “conservative”?

Readings:

• Price, “A Discourse on the Love of Our Country,” (1789), pp. 195–96
• Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in France, (1790), pp. 3–70

Discussion Questions:

Reflections on the Revolution in France:

1. The Reflections is Burke’s masterpiece. You will see that Burke is writing (at least partially) in response to someone called Richard Price, and we read the last two pages of Price’s essay that so provoked Burke. What is it about his views that so outrages Burke?
2. The Reflections is quintessentially Burkean (and difficult for philosophers) in the way it moves between immediate questions of practice and deep theoretical reflections. This is not a text of systematic theoretical philosophy. Rather, much of the theorizing occurs to shed light on a practical point. As such, it comes often unexpectedly and without warning before flowing back into the practical analysis. Pay special attention to, and reflect on, the momentary but deep theoretical reflections.
3. For those of you who have read Locke’s Second Treatise, how does Burke’s form, method, and argument compare? In what ways is Burke similar to Locke and in what ways different? Does it make sense to label Locke a liberal and Burke a conservative? Why of why not?
4. As you read, focus in particular on Burke’s views of:

•  liberty: British v. French, rational v. irrational, regulated v. unregulated;
•  equality and inequality, natural and social;
• prudence;
• human nature, the state of nature, etc.;
• the nature and ends of government;
• the social contract;
• reason and its limits;
• the necessity of “little platoons” (p. 40);
• the royal family;
• chivalry and its benefits;
• religion;
  prejudice and superstition;
• philosophy, metaphysics, speculation, the problems of the new metaphysics;
•  the new classes in France;
• the National Assembly;
• fanaticism;
• revolution: permissible? wise? What are its tendencies?

Readings:

• Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in France, pp. 70–168

Discussion Questions:

1. See previous day’s questions for Reflections.

Readings:

• Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in France, pp. 168–210

Discussion Questions:

1. See previous day’s questions for Reflections.